***** SPOILER ALERT *****
I picked up the book pictured here at my church's Trash & Treasure sale a couple of years ago. It got buried on my bookshelf until I recently came across it again while deciding what to read next for the Cozy Mystery Challenge. Originally published in 1930, my copy is from the 1942 first printing of the "Pocket BOOKS" edition.
I was not familiar with Mary Roberts Rinehart, so I decided to look her up at Wikipedia before beginning the book. Can you imagine my horror and disappointment as I read the following!?!
I'll never know to what extent this knowledge affected my opinion of the novel. Throughout the entire book I found myself constantly "watching" the butler. Perhaps that's why I found the cast of characters rather boring and difficult to relate to. In fact, some of the players downright irritated me, including the narrator! It took me over a week to get through what should have been a quick read. The plot wasn't that bad, though, and I think under different circumstances I would have enjoyed it much more than I did.The phrase "The butler did it", which has become a cliche, came from Rinehart's novel The Door, in which the butler actually did do it although that exact phrase does not actually appear in the work.
Has anyone else read this novel or any other books by Mary Roberts Rinehart?






